1 2 3 4 5 6 7

Small Claims Court Appearance: What to Expect & What Happens After

You've done the prep work, served the summons, and now it's time for the court hearing. This might feel daunting, but it's your chance to explain your side to the Commissioner. Being prepared and knowing what to expect can make a big difference. Let's walk through it.

What Happens at the Hearing? A Step-by-Step Guide

Small Claims Court hearings are designed to be less formal than other courts, with relaxed rules of evidence. The Commissioner leads the process inquisitorially, meaning they actively ask questions to find the facts. Here’s a typical flow:

1. Arriving at Court: Be Early!

Plan to arrive at the courthouse at least 30 minutes before your scheduled hearing time. This gives you breathing room to find parking, go through any security checks, locate the correct courtroom, and check in with the court clerk (the official who manages the courtroom). Let them know you've arrived for your case.

2. Before You Go In: Get Ready

You'll likely wait outside the courtroom or in a designated area. Use this time to quickly review your notes and make sure your documents (the original letter of demand, summons, proof of service, and all your evidence) are organised and easy to access. Take a few deep breaths – it's normal to be nervous!

3. In the Courtroom: Presenting Your Case

When your case name is called, you'll enter the courtroom and go to the designated spot. Remember, proceedings are usually held in open court. The person presiding is a Commissioner, not a Judge. Stand up when the Commissioner enters or when you are speaking to them to show respect.

  • Taking the Oath: Before testifying, you (and any witnesses) will need to take an oath or make a solemn affirmation to tell the truth, administered by the Commissioner or clerk.
  • Stating Your Claim: The Commissioner will likely ask you (the Plaintiff) to explain your claim first. Speak clearly and stick to the facts. Explain what happened, when it happened, and what you are asking the court to order (e.g., payment of RXXXX). You can present your evidence either orally or in writing. Refer to your documents.
  • Defendant's Turn: After you've spoken, the person you're claiming against (the Defendant) will get their chance to respond and present their side, including any counterclaim. Listen carefully without interrupting.
  • Questioning (Inquisitorial Process): The Commissioner will ask questions to both parties and any witnesses to clarify facts. Direct questioning or cross-examination between parties is generally not allowed, but the Commissioner might permit you to ask specific questions through them or directly. Answer honestly and directly.

4. The Decision (Judgment)

Once the Commissioner has heard everything, they will make a decision, called a judgment. Possible judgments include:

  • Judgment for the plaintiff (you win your claim, fully or partially).
  • Judgment for the defendant (you lose, or they win their counterclaim).
  • Absolution from the instance (neither party proved their case sufficiently).
  • An order regarding costs (usually limited to court fees, summons fee, and Sheriff's costs).

The Commissioner might give the judgment immediately or deliver it later. They may also inquire about the judgment debtor's ability to pay and potentially order payment in instalments right away.

What if Someone Doesn't Show Up? (Default Judgment)

If the defendant doesn't appear after being properly served with the summons, you can ask the court for judgment by default, provided you can prove your claim and the defendant's liability. Similarly, if you (the plaintiff) don't appear, the defendant can ask for your claim to be dismissed and potentially get judgment on their counterclaim. A judgment given in someone's absence can sometimes be rescinded (cancelled) later upon application under specific conditions.

Common Questions About Court Day

Here are answers to some frequently asked questions:

Bring the originals (and ideally 2 copies) of: Your Letter of Demand, your Summons, the Proof of Service (Affidavit, Sheriff's Return, or Postal Slip), and ALL evidence supporting your claim (contracts, invoices, receipts, photos, relevant messages).

Neat and tidy shows respect. Clean trousers/skirt, a buttoned shirt/blouse, or a simple dress. Avoid casual wear like t-shirts with slogans, shorts, flip-flops, or hats.

Address them respectfully as "Commissioner". Stand when speaking to them or when they speak to you. Wait for your turn.

It's normal! Preparation builds confidence. Know your key points, have documents organised. Speak slowly and clearly. Remember, the Commissioner uses an inquisitorial process to understand the facts fairly.

Generally, no. Parties must appear in person. Legal representation (like lawyers) is not allowed during the hearing. A friend can offer moral support but cannot argue your case.

Being late is risky. The Commissioner could postpone or dismiss your case. Aim to arrive 30-45 minutes early.

Don't interrupt. Avoid raising your voice or using rude language. Stick to the facts. Keep your phone off. Disrespectful behaviour can be considered contempt of court.

After the Judgment: What Happens Next?

So, the hearing is over, and the Commissioner has given judgment. What now? It depends on the outcome and if the defendant complies.

Understanding the Judgment & Initial Steps

  • Judgment Details: Make sure you understand exactly what the court ordered (payment amount, actions required, any deadlines).
  • Payment Direct: Any money ordered must be paid directly by the judgment debtor to the judgment creditor (you, if you won).
  • Immediate Financial Inquiry: Right after giving a money judgment, the court must ask the debtor if they can pay immediately. If not, the court can conduct an inquiry into their financial position and may order payment in instalments.
  • Debtor's Offer (If No Instalment Order): If the court didn't make an instalment order, the debtor has 10 days after judgment to make you a written offer to pay in instalments (using Form 9). If you accept, you can ask the Clerk (using Form 10) to make this offer an official court order.

Scenario 1: Judgment in Your Favour & Defendant Pays

Ideal outcome! If the court ruled for you and the defendant pays as ordered (or per the instalment plan), the matter is settled. Keep proof of payment.

Scenario 2: Judgment Against You (Claim Dismissed / Absolution)

If your claim was dismissed or absolution was granted, your case in the Small Claims Court usually ends. Judgments are final, and there's no appeal. (Review is possible only on very limited grounds like lack of jurisdiction or gross irregularity.)

Scenario 3: Judgment in Your Favour... But Defendant Doesn't Pay

This is where enforcement comes in. If the defendant ignores the judgment or misses payments on an instalment order, you must take action.

Important Note on Judgment Type: The enforcement process differs slightly:

  • For Money Judgments: Enforcement happens via the Magistrate's Court process after referral.
  • For Delivery/Ejectment: The SCC Clerk can issue a warrant directly.

Enforcing a Money Judgment: Referral to Magistrate's Court

If the defendant fails to pay a money judgment within 10 days (or defaults on an instalment order), you must apply to the SCC Clerk to refer the matter for execution via the Magistrate's Court.

1. Apply to the SCC Clerk for Referral

You need to lodge a written application (use Form 11) with the Clerk of the Small Claims Court where judgment was granted. This application must include an affidavit stating:

  • The amount still owing under the judgment (and any costs).
  • How you calculated that amount (showing any payments received).

2. Clerk Transmits Documents

The SCC Clerk will then send your affidavit, along with a certified copy of the SCC judgment, to the Clerk of the Magistrate's Court for the district where the defendant resides, works, or (if a company) has its registered office/main business place.

3. Execution via Magistrate's Court

Once the Magistrate's Court Clerk receives and registers the documents, the judgment is treated as if it were originally granted in the Magistrate's Court. You can then use the standard Magistrate's Court procedures to execute the judgment, primarily by obtaining a Warrant of Execution against Movable Property from the Magistrate's Court Clerk and instructing the Sheriff.

4. The Sheriff's Role (Magistrate's Court Process)

You instruct the Sheriff (and pay their fees) to execute the Magistrate's Court Warrant. The Sheriff attempts to attach and sell the defendant's movable property (excluding essential items protected by law) to satisfy the debt. If successful, the proceeds (less costs) are paid to you.

Find the correct Sheriff here.

Enforcing Judgments for Delivery or Ejectment

If the court ordered the defendant to return specific property to you or to vacate premises (ejectment), and they fail to comply, the process is slightly different:

  • You can approach the Clerk of the Small Claims Court directly.
  • Ask the Clerk to issue a Warrant for the Surrender of Goods (Form 2) or a Warrant of Ejectment (Form 3), as appropriate.
  • This warrant is addressed to the Sheriff, authorising them to take the property or eject the defendant. You will still need to instruct the Sheriff and pay their fees.
Back to Summons Back to Homepage